Pooling of human capital for the unofficial 'Two Plus Two Portfolio'

[missmisery]

I like the general idea but if everyone post their favorite stocks, I believe it will be quite a mess to build a portfolio around this.

If your goal is to learn about investing by looking at how others do it, then you could simply ask everyone to post 1-3 stocks they like along with a detailed analysis as to why it is a good thing to invest in these particular stocks. Then you could simply keep track of all the suggested stocks and see if it outperforms the market in a certain time frame horizon.