**American Idol The Top 3

[ajmargarine]

Typical Taylor in song 3. Meh.

[disjunction]

Taylor pandering to the base.

I don't think much changed tonight. If you liked Elliott or Taylor before today you still like them. Some husbands will be sleeping on the couch if they vote Kat, but on the flip side, hearing your first good rendition of "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" makes some people spaz.

[ajmargarine]

Taylor pandered to his base twice tonite. Which is probably good because he has the largest base of the three remaining. He also had the performance of the night with his Joe Cocker tune. It would be a real shocker if he didn't make it to the finals, and IMO there's little chance he doesn't make it.

Kat had the second best performance of the night with Over the Rainbow. Her other two songs were pretty meh, however. Elliot gave the most consistent performances of the night. I also think he is the most logical choice to get the most Chris votes. Trouble is he didn't really knock one out of the park tonite.

Those two will be the bottom two. I'll say Kat goes home.

[epdaws]

[ QUOTE ]
Taylor pandered to his base twice tonite.

[/ QUOTE ]

Right, cause he picked the first song. Oh, wait, he didn't. It would have been more of a pander if he took it over the top.

On his last song, you either like it or you don't, but even if you don't, you have to appreciate that this guy is unique. He can sing surprisingly well when he's moving like that, and it beats the life out of the canned pop we listen to on the radio now.

With EY, you either like him or you don't, but it's hard to think of him as anything but vanilla. And lame when he tries to show any kind of personality.

[ QUOTE ]
he didn't really knock one out of the park tonite.

[/ QUOTE ]

Also, you are obsessed with softball references, Softball Guy!

[Mac]

[ QUOTE ]

He also had the performance of the night with his Joe Cocker tune. Kat had the second best performance of the night with Over the Rainbow.


[/ QUOTE ]

They were both really good, but Taylor didn't even attempt the big notes. IMO, these are your final two, but I thought Kat was stronger tonight.

- Mac

[dlk9s]

[ QUOTE ]
LMAO @ "Have A Good Time Funky Taylor".

Randy dethrones Paula for most inane commentary of the night.

[/ QUOTE ]

Sounded like a camp counselor talking to a retarded kid.

[puckboy]

Why is this thread here, i'm ashamed to even be posting in it. I think I will find an american idol blog somewhere on the internet and post a poker question.

[Yeti]

puckboy,

Get the hell out of here.

[Yeti]

All,

I think those still predicting Katherine to go tomorrow are being pretty optimistic. Having said that, nothing would make me happier.

[ajmargarine]

[ QUOTE ]
All,

I think those still predicting Katherine to go tomorrow are being pretty optimistic. Having said that, nothing would make me happier.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah, I think my prediction was a little more heart than head. [img]/images/graemlins/crazy.gif[/img]