Help settle a debate: this guy's bluff good or bad?

[EnoBaLL]

good responses

[riskofruin]

Ansky wrote "Your image may be crazy LAG but not every crazy LAG is capable of bluff shoving here. It just comes down to if the villain 1) Thinks you are capable of a bluff here. 2) Knows whether or not you know that."

But in what cases would the villian fulfill the #1 but not #2? If the villian knows you are capable of bluffing in a certain spot, then isnt it implied that the villian knows that you know that the villian knows you are capable of bluffing in that spot?