OOT Survivor VII RJ vs. DB / Idi vs. Mr. Francis

[TheMetetron]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
All,

Discussion and rulings with [censored] are finished. The final vote count is

Exile DB 124
Exile RJ 123

[censored] will post more about any rulings that took place, and I will make the spreadsheet available as soon as possible.

[/ QUOTE ]

oops

I had to rule on gimmick accounts and I decided that the spirit of survivor was that each poster gets one vote, and has to do it in the open. I didnt want things swayed by gimmick accounts of multiple accounts. therefore if an account was identified as a secondary account of a poster who had already voted, the vote was not counted.

[/ QUOTE ]

Unless gimmick accounts were explicity stated as a no-no in the original rules, I think is is a bad decision.

[/ QUOTE ]

Dids makes a really good point since samjones even explicitly said gimmicks were allowed if they qualified while the voting was going on. It seems a lot to me like [censored] trying to tamper results so DB is gone.

[censored] it doesn't matter. Just go with the actual results without screwing around and changing the rules. He loses next time (to hopefully Diablo).