*Official Fantasy Football "What Do You Think of This Trade" Thread* 2

[NLSoldier]

brees for colston seems like a total waste to me. If you can get johnson for him then I like it a lot.

[splashpot]

Lol....I will never understand why anyone would ever carry 3 QBs unless it's a start 2QB league. And now that guy wants to offer you a 4th one?!?!? Do these guys even look at what they're offering?

If you can get any of his WRs for Colston, I'd probably do it. In this order Andre > Chambers = Glenn > Mason.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
Lol....I will never understand why anyone would ever carry 3 QBs unless it's a start 2QB league. And now that guy wants to offer you a 4th one?!?!? Do these guys even look at what they're offering?

If you can get any of his WRs for Colston, I'd probably do it. In this order Andre > Chambers = Glenn > Mason.

[/ QUOTE ]

I wouldnt get rid of colston for those guys other than andre.

Colston is very valuable if he can be started at TE.

Id instead trade LJ smith for one of those other WRs.

[splashpot]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Lol....I will never understand why anyone would ever carry 3 QBs unless it's a start 2QB league. And now that guy wants to offer you a 4th one?!?!? Do these guys even look at what they're offering?

If you can get any of his WRs for Colston, I'd probably do it. In this order Andre > Chambers = Glenn > Mason.

[/ QUOTE ]

I wouldnt get rid of colston for those guys other than andre.

Colston is very valuable if he can be started at TE.

Id instead trade LJ smith for one of those other WRs.

[/ QUOTE ]
Mason is probably pushing it, but I'd have no problem trading Colston for either Chambers or Glenn.

[J_V]

The way our keeper league works means that if I don't trade LT this year, I lose him. So here is the deal on the table:

I get Shaun Alexander and Lauwrence Maroney for LT.

I get to keep Lawrence Maroney next year as my 3rd keeper because he is a rookie.

How do you guys feel about that?

[Kneel B4 Zod]

[ QUOTE ]
The way our keeper league works means that if I don't trade LT this year, I lose him. So here is the deal on the table:

I get Shaun Alexander and Lauwrence Maroney for LT.

I get to keep Lawrence Maroney next year as my 3rd keeper because he is a rookie.

How do you guys feel about that?

[/ QUOTE ]

do you also get to keep SA? how exactly do your keep rules work?

Maroney has TREMENDOUS UPSIDE POTENTIAL! the NE Oline is very good, and they are all signed to medium/long term deals. if they resign TE Graham (likely) you're looking at a great run foundation for years to come, and Maroney looks like the real deal.

[J_V]

You get to keep 2 keepers each year, but no longer than 2 years. And you can keep a rookie keeper for one year. So if I didn't trade, i would have to keep, a second tier running back like deshaun foster and LT goes into the draft.

If I trade, I keep SA, Maroney and a WR. So, I have to trade LT, so the question is trying to get as much as I can.

I was hoping you guys could give me your thoughts on Shaun Alexander for the next couple years? Is he gonna be a top back next year, or should I get something like Gore or Willie Parker and 1st round draft pick?

[xorbie]

SA should be better than Parker or Gore, but I'm not sure he'll match last year's production ever again. I also wouldn't trade LT now, not until SA gets better. LT has some good games coming up and SA has... a broken foot.

[NLSoldier]

Interesting spot J_V. I think Alexander and Maroney looks like a good deal especially if he will let you wait another week till SA is healthy.

[NLSoldier]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Lol....I will never understand why anyone would ever carry 3 QBs unless it's a start 2QB league. And now that guy wants to offer you a 4th one?!?!? Do these guys even look at what they're offering?

If you can get any of his WRs for Colston, I'd probably do it. In this order Andre > Chambers = Glenn > Mason.

[/ QUOTE ]

I wouldnt get rid of colston for those guys other than andre.

Colston is very valuable if he can be started at TE.

Id instead trade LJ smith for one of those other WRs.

[/ QUOTE ]
Mason is probably pushing it, but I'd have no problem trading Colston for either Chambers or Glenn.

[/ QUOTE ]

I dunno. Colston so far has been more productive than Chambers and just as productive as glen, and hes playing at TE!

I do agree that by the end of the year both of them may have better numbers than colston but I dont think by enough to compensate for the fact that you can use him as a TE.

That said I think chambers would be my second choice because his perceived value is prob lower right now but I think his actual value is higher than Glenns.