*Official Fantasy Football "What Do You Think of This Trade" Thread*

[MEbenhoe]

[ QUOTE ]


He is interested in trading McNabb. What should I offer? What should be my worst case scenario?

[/ QUOTE ]

you should stick with Bulger and be picking someone up off the waiver wire to replace Green (well actually you should've already done this before all the free agent QBs were pillaged but oh well). Trading any of your top RBs or WRs for McNabb would be foolish.

[Black Aces 518]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]


He is interested in trading McNabb. What should I offer? What should be my worst case scenario?

[/ QUOTE ]

you should stick with Bulger and be picking someone up off the waiver wire to replace Green (well actually you should've already done this before all the free agent QBs were pillaged but oh well). Trading any of your top RBs or WRs for McNabb would be foolish.

[/ QUOTE ]

Well, Bulger's bye week is after Green is projected back. And this league is full of donks and a couple autodrafters so the QB pickins are awful. I put in for Grossman, but was 4th in the waiver order and missed. Frye, Johnson, Losman, Walter, Collins and Huard are the only available starters. Grossman and Pennington are the only guys who got picked up after the start of the season. 29 QBs and 21 Defenses on the rosters of the 12 teams combined. Makes it suck also to play the "smart" waiver wire defense game.

[Black Aces 518]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Dynasty league, scoring only (ie, TDs/2pt conversions, or FG/XP for kickers). Less than 10 YD TDs = 6, 10-39 YD TDs = 9, 40+ YD TDs = 12. Scoring TDs out of position (rush TDs for QBs, recieving for RBs, etc) = double points.



I give up my first round pick in next year's rookie draft for Brian Westbrook.

My RBs are Caddy, Julius Jones, Frank Gore, Michael Turner and Verron Haynes, with Dom Davis on IR.

Factoring in that we get double points for receiving TDs from running backs, I think Westbrook for a (hopefully low) first round rookie is a steal. Thoughts?

[/ QUOTE ]

Pulled the trigger on this, still wouldn't mind some thoughts on it.

[/ QUOTE ]

I think the dbl point for receiving TDs makes this a smart move.

[MacGuyV]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]


He is interested in trading McNabb. What should I offer? What should be my worst case scenario?

[/ QUOTE ]

you should stick with Bulger and be picking someone up off the waiver wire to replace Green (well actually you should've already done this before all the free agent QBs were pillaged but oh well). Trading any of your top RBs or WRs for McNabb would be foolish.

[/ QUOTE ]

Well, Bulger's bye week is after Green is projected back. And this league is full of donks and a couple autodrafters so the QB pickins are awful. I put in for Grossman, but was 4th in the waiver order and missed. Frye, Johnson, Losman, Walter, Collins and Huard are the only available starters. Grossman and Pennington are the only guys who got picked up after the start of the season. 29 QBs and 21 Defenses on the rosters of the 12 teams combined. Makes it suck also to play the "smart" waiver wire defense game.

[/ QUOTE ]

I think that's the first time I've seen other fantasy owners referred to as "donks". Nicely done.

[Black Aces 518]

Also, if you notice, I mixed in the solid theme also of "these guys are so bad that I can't beat them." [img]/images/graemlins/laugh.gif[/img]

[SL__72]

Someone offered me Eddie Kennison for Kellen Winslow.

My recievers right now:

Chad Johnson, Anquin Boldin, Matt Jones and
Laveranues Coles. My TEs are Kellen Winslow and Vernon Davis.

1pt/20yds, 6pt/TD, start 3WR and 1TE.

[kyro]

You have 3 very solid starters, and a decent backup. Unless 2 of those 4 have the same bye week, I don't see how this could possibly benefit you.

How much of a downgrade is Winslow to Davis?

[kyro]

Kid has offered me Marc Bulger and Julius Jones for Chester Taylor.

QBs: Matt Hasselbeck and David Carr
RBs: LT, Taylor, Cadillac and DeAngelo Williams.

Start 2 QBs and 2 RBs.

[SL__72]

I'm really not sure how much of a downgrade it is... or even if it is a downgrade.

The thing I'm worried about is both Coles and Matt Jones are questionable going into next week.

[Black Aces 518]

[ QUOTE ]
You have 3 very solid starters, and a decent backup. Unless 2 of those 4 have the same bye week, I don't see how this could possibly benefit you.

How much of a downgrade is Winslow to Davis?

[/ QUOTE ]

Agree with this. I think Winslow is more intrinsic to CLE's offense than Davis is to SFO's at this point. Kennison can't crack your starting lineup. No go.