**American Idol The Top 3

[revots33]

[ QUOTE ]
I disagree. Simon's song is perfect for her. She will absolutely nail a broadway-type song. I also like the other choice as long as she does not go over the top with it. She has a beautiful voice and these songs should be perfect for her.


[/ QUOTE ]

I agree that "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" is a good choice. It's the type of cabaret song that suits Kat.

But I disagree that she has a beautiful voice. She is college glee-club average on her best nights, and painfully shrill on her bad nights. And she's had more bad nights than good. She should've been gone right after Mandisa.

Elliott's choices, I think, are worse than Kat's. I hope he pulls out a showstopper as his personal choice, because I'm rooting for him to make the final.