Was I justified or out of line

[Atlanta Andrew]

Kampf, you're way wrong.

Whether the rule can technically be enforced here depends on the card room management and might go either way based on a number of factors.

Whether the rule should be enforced is another story, though. For OP or any player to try and take down this pot by using a rule outside of its intended purpose is angleshooting and very out of line. I would only consider using this rule in a similar situation if the violater might actually be cheating, which is basically never.

If you want to be a nit about the rules at this homegame, insist that violater shows both cards and explain the rule so he knows not to break it again.

-Andrew