Question on raising/"one chip rule"

[rageotones]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Guys,

It's a call. As usual, in such situations, if you're confused just read RR's explanation.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yep. It took me til last year in the WSOP to understand the rule. Limit event, 300/600 level, on the turn player A bets 600 with a 500 and a 100 chip, player B raises with two 500 chips and two 100 chips. Player C throws out two 1k chips, many at the table understand he intended to raise based on flop action. Player A folds, player B tries to 4 bet when it is pointed out by someone not in the hand that player C only called the bet. Players B, and C protest, floor is called, its ruled a call. Player A is now livid, as he would have called for one more bet knowing player B could not reraise. Player A gets a nice 20 minute time out for swearing at the floorman, player C is close to the same, player B is mad too. The guy who said the rule and asked for the floor is an experienced tournament pro (who's name I don't know sadly) and was clearly correct but pissed everyone off. Good times.

-DeathDonkey

[/ QUOTE ]

hmmmm....so everyone in the hand(everyone that matters at this point) think it's a raise, and some guy not in the hand challenges it?

sounds like everyone saying this is CLEARLY a call is wrong regardless of if this is actually the correct ruling.