Best pop/rock band

[nath]

[ QUOTE ]
If college radio liked it, it probably doesn't qualify. If college radio loved it, it certainly doesn't.

[/ QUOTE ]

Geez, that's too bad, because I think the Exploding Hearts would win this running away if half the band didn't die in a van crash. By that I mean they're not only great but I think they fit the exact description of what you want here. I also think the New Pornographers and Ted Leo (especially Ted Leo)are still very strong contenders, and I love the Hold Steady more than anyone else does, apparently.

Nothing college rock? Um... let's see, the Strokes and Franz Ferdinand already mentioned. Older White Stripes (i.e. the first 3 albums). I haven't delved into all-time yet because I don't think it's much use to the list if they aren't still making music, and then it just becomes "name your favorite band". That said, of the ones listed I tink the Kinks are probably closest to fulfilling what you're looking for. The Who is also a good choice.