Hermione's New Competition

[madnak]

I don't like either of them.

I thought Watson was a decent Hermione in the first couple movies, but in the last one I hated her performance. She doesn't seem to be making an attempt at portraying Hermione, she's just trying to look all pretty. And she's starting to act more like a ditzy teenager than a nerdy know-it-all.

I need to see Luna in action before really judging her, but I doubt this girl can pull it off. Luna is one of my favorite characters and I don't like thinking about how she'll be portrayed. I think Luna should be earnest but vacant, and I just don't see it in this girl. Also it's clear in the books that Luna's appearance is very "different."

Ah well.