**American Idol The Top 3

[2easy]

[ QUOTE ]
2easy,

i'm not about to take it any lower to a fourth-grade girls argument over which teen pop sensation we like better.

That being said, I onced derrived 100% of my non-gambling income as a writer, primarily writing as a music critic.

But there's a definitive difference between someone with a classically "great" voice and someone who doesn't have it. Kat has formal training and she has natural talent. I'm not going to say that you...don't love and enjoy Taylor and his voice and his spastic dancing. But trying to act like (Taylor's) got some phenominal voice isn't just going to fly with anyone serious...

[/ QUOTE ]

i dont recall making any comment whatsoever about taylor, much less anything close to what you are talking about here.

however, i did comment regarding your contentions about kat vs clarkson, kat's vs chris's futures and kat's, elliot's and taylor's future marketability, none of which did you address in your response(?) to me.

somehow your "response" to what i addressed ...[img]/images/graemlins/confused.gif[/img]... became just another taylor-bashing/kat-pimping diatribe by yourself.

maybe strawman arguements/obfuscation is stock in trade for a "professional" music writer/critic.

again, a bit over the top, aren't we?



p.s. starting fifth grade this fall?