*Official Fantasy Football "What Do You Think of This Trade" Thread*

[CharlieDontSurf]

Figure this might spare some of the clutter.

[CharlieDontSurf]

I Got
Gates-WR
Horn-WR
Randal El-WR

I gave
VDavis-TE
Branch-WR
KCurtis-WR

1 point per 10 yrds...6 points for TD+2 for 25+, plus 4 for 50+
100yrds=5 points

My other WR's are Jennings-GB, CChambers-Mia, CJohnson-Cinn, CWilson-Pitt
We start 3 WR and a Flex which can be a WR/TE etc

[CharlieDontSurf]

Agree or Disagree

Gates far superior to VDavis
Branch and Horn are a wash
Curtis superior to Randel EL

so basically I gave up a better #3 WR(I have Chmabers and ChadJ who are auto starts) to get the best TE.

[Caldarooni]

Who knows?

VDavis is such an unknown. I strongly disagree that Branch and Horn are a wash. However, as of now, with Branch's status still unknown its fine. But if he starts the season. . .

[rwperu34]

[ QUOTE ]
I Got
Gates-WR
Horn-WR
Randal El-WR

I gave
VDavis-TE
Branch-WR
KCurtis-WR

1 point per 10 yrds...6 points for TD+2 for 25+, plus 4 for 50+
100yrds=5 points

My other WR's are Jennings-GB, CChambers-Mia, CJohnson-Cinn, CWilson-Pitt
We start 3 WR and a Flex which can be a WR/TE etc

[/ QUOTE ]

This is what we refer to in my baseball league as a "rape job". Getting Gates and two nags for that package would be worthwhile. Getting Horn is just a bonus.

[rwperu34]

[ QUOTE ]
Agree or Disagree

Gates far superior to VDavis
Branch and Horn are a wash
Curtis superior to Randel EL

so basically I gave up a better #3 WR(I have Chmabers and ChadJ who are auto starts) to get the best TE.

[/ QUOTE ]

Disagree.

Gates > Branch
Horn > Curtis
Randle El > Davis

[ZBTHorton]

You got the best of the trade by about 30 points over the period of the season, according to my formula.

[CharlieDontSurf]

[ QUOTE ]
Who knows?

VDavis is such an unknown. I strongly disagree that Branch and Horn are a wash. However, as of now, with Branch's status still unknown its fine. But if he starts the season. . .

[/ QUOTE ]

Horn #1 on a team that will be down by 15 points every game.
He had a crap year last year but there were a lot of factors for that...and having Brooks as your QB never helps.

Branch while he has the potential for a breakout year...is currently a holdout and is on a team where they seem to throw to everyone and their mother every week.

I see Horn being more consistent game in game out then Branch who I see having a great game then vanishing then a great game ...etc etc
ESPN
21. Joe Horn
22. Lee Evans
23. Rod Smith
24. Nate Burleson
25. Eddie Kennison
26. Derrick Mason
27. Terry Glenn
28. Deion Branch

footballguys projections
29 Deion Branch NE/6 67rec 905yrd 13.5av 5tds 120.9pts
31-Joe Horn NO/7 66rec 881yrds 13.3av 5tds 118.1pts

so a push.

Though Branch is more likely for a huge breakout...but being on the Pats hurts that.

[CharlieDontSurf]

[ QUOTE ]
You got the best of the trade by about 30 points over the period of the season, according to my formula.

[/ QUOTE ]

ZBT....I now always see you as that Lazlo guy from RS disappearing into the closet to pour over his FFB formula lol

[ZBTHorton]

Haha. Pretty much.

The worst part of my week this week was moving Cedric Houston from a 120 point RB to a 60 point RB. :-(