**American Idol The Top 3

[Yeti]

Ugh.

[disjunction]

Elliott -- meh. Same old same old.

Kat -- It is just not fair giving only one of the three performers "Somewhere Over the Rainbow". Given that song, I didn't think she was especially great, but like I said earlier in the thread, what competent singer isn't going to sound absolutely amazing with that song? I also think that song will sound a little better live than on TV.

[Mac]

Kat pwns Taylor. She killed it.

[Gary Stevenson]

damn. taylor did well with that. GO KAT/ELLIOT

[ajmargarine]

Taylor re-pwns with Joe Cocker.

Elliot better have something real real real special in store, or he goes home, unless Kat is a complete dufus in her final song.

[disjunction]

Wow great song choice by Randy. That's the first time I can remember liking Taylor in a song that was understated, as opposed to over-the-top. Best of the night so far, I think.

[Yeti]

Anything you can do.......

[terrapin314]

Nice recovery by Taylor.

Elliott better nail it if he wants to make final two.

[disjunction]

[ QUOTE ]
Nice recovery by Taylor.

Elliott better nail it if he wants to make final two.

[/ QUOTE ]

I wouldn't think many votes are swinging tonight. The main vote-swinger was Kat's snapping at the judges.

[dlk9s]

Tonight was rigged for Taylor and against Elliott (with Katharine in the middle somewhere).

Taylor had this show handed to him on a plate with those first two song choices. While I felt his first song was the same old schtick, most people love that stuff.

Elliot's first song choice was ok, but nobody was going to care about the second one, even if he sang it great.

Taylor and Katharine (for her second song) had choices people could get into. Elliot didn't. It seemed like the other two sang longer than he did, too.

Strange.