Re: Most Overrated Baseball Players of All-Time
I don't understand how McGuire is overrated, seems like the argument Jack is making is more for how Thomas is underrated.
The argument against Ripkin ignores eras, which is dump. Compare Cal's numbers to his peers and they look a lot better.
Any god fearing stathead who came up between 96-00 will tell you that the answer is obviously Joe Carter.
Jeter is 2nd.
|