[NajdorfDefense]

[ QUOTE ]
i have to say in this mcnabb vs garcia argument that its not really who was better, clearly mcnabb is more talented, garcia more accurate.Garcia is very very good in the west coast offense, which is why he did so well with san fran, because he had TO to throw to [and Jerry Rice!] and has never put up similar numbers since, which is why he couldn't play in Cleveland or Detroit

[/ QUOTE ]

McNabb with TO and Jerry Rice at WR would have won at least 3 Super Bowls, likely more [2001, 2003, 2004, maybe 2000 and 2002]. Instead we had CHARLES FREAKING JOHNSON and TORRANCE SMALL and then Stinkston and Trash. Vomit.

Garcia's top 2 wideouts, by contrast in his first PB year, had >2200 yds receiving and 20 TDs in a similar offense. Because TO+Rice >>>>>>>>> Small and Johnson.

The past years, the QB rankings have been thus:
Manning
Brady
[gap]
Palmer
McNabb
Brees
Bulger
Hasselback
Roeth
[gap]
Eli
Favre
Vick
Plummer/Kitna/etc
everyone else