View Single Post
  #143  
Old 11-20-2007, 07:21 PM
bottomset bottomset is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: middleset ftw
Posts: 12,983
Default Re: jimmy rollins is a yambag

[ QUOTE ]
this isnt the best player award, it is the most valuable player award. THe idea is to win games, and a guy like Hanley on a team that didnt win a lot of games gets less consideration than a guy on a team that does

But i guess this doesnt answer your question does it. My ballot probably would have had Wright 2nd place behind Rollins -- mostly yes because the Phillies won the division. So i guess i am as dumb as the voters


[/ QUOTE ]

no all you are saying is value other 24 guys is more important that true value for the individual

if player A is worth 12wins, the rest of his team is worth 60
player B is worth 11wins, the rest of his team is worth 85

player A is more valueable, playerB's team is better its pretty simple(as long as playing time is pretty close)

the best player(for the season) by definition has the most value
Reply With Quote