[Sciolist]

I would firstly tell CO how much I am enjoying not giving him "his" money back. He deserves it.

I would really rather have not seen the flop being dealt, as my instinct would be to give UTG his equity in the pot - i.e, ~33% of it. I would look at his preflop equity, not what happened on the rabbit hunting.

However, making this kind of decision, you have to be aware that most people will not do the same for you.