[toybux]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I give Steve Smith, L. Maroney, and Garrard for Peyton Manning.

My above trade seems really clearly good for me, but a couple different people I've talked to don't think so. I think they're nuts, trying to get some feedback to see if there are reasons this is bad that make sense.

[/ QUOTE ]

Depends who your old QB was (Garrard) and who your WRs and RBs are.

[/ QUOTE ]

My QB's were Cutler and Garrard. My WRs were Moss, S. Smith, Welker, Branch, Roscoe Parrish, and I have Witten at TE. My RBs are Portis, Peterson (Min), Wynn, and Davenport. I had Stallworth too but he was traded separately.

I figured that Smith was likely at a high point right now given Delhomme's surgery. Maroney's play so far plus his injury plus Morris looking good made me not like his value a whole lot. Garrard and Cutler both seem like solid backups, but picking up Manning would add a lot to my offense. As is after the trade, I have a pretty sick starting lineup for a 14 team league. (P.Manning, Moss, Welker, Portis, Peterson (MIN) and Witten)

Edit: It is also worth mentioning for the observant FF player that I picked up Warner from FA for week 6 (and maybe future tradebait), as both Cutler and Manning are on bye.