Re: Kendall traded...
[ QUOTE ]
Teams have won Super Bowls with much worse than Chad Pennington. If you want to argue that the Jets need a Manning/Palmer to win the Super Bowl, then fine, you win. But to say Chad is not a top 10 QB is just wrong.(I realize saying Top 10 is a bit misleading as he is more like between 7-10)
[/ QUOTE ]
That is my point, that the Jets, at this point, need an elite QB to go to the SB. I get what you are saying, guys like Trent Dilfer have won SBs. But he had the best defense in football and an amazing O-Line, 2 things that the Jets currently lack. Add that with his inconsistency, and I don't believe he is the right long-term option. I wouldn't say he is a top 10 QB but he's no worse than top 15. After Manning, Brady, Palmer, Brees, Bulger and McNabb, you can argue for a number of QB's filling out the top 10. I would rather have Young, Rivers, Hasselbeck and Favre. I assume you agree with me that the Pittsburgh game was in fact, a terrible game for Chad.
|