[FortunaMaximus]

[ QUOTE ]
There are people who torture and kill cats for the fun of it on holloween. If we lived in a lawless society, I think it would be more fun to find the people that do this and torture and kill them.

Would I be wrong to do that? Why?

[/ QUOTE ]

Certainly not, if you choose that as an individual expression of justice. Probably better to isolate them and let them "Kilkenny cat" themselves.

But if you can render judgments with a probability of 1, as stated in reply above, then I guess you're qualified, aren't you.

Thing is, I don't think there's anybody on this planet, human or otherwise, that can make this judgment yet. Willing to be convinced otherwise.

It should be implied that if an individual or a collection of individuals are capable of creating those situations where perfectly correct judgments can be carried out, they also have the ability to create situations where the individual or individuals in question with regards to bring harm to cats, and crimes of that sort can express their inclinations without actually harming cats. They should do so, actually. It ain't a crime to build the walls.

And they end up judging themselves in the end and coming to their own resolutions. Or they perish. One needn't have a proactive hand in the process, just the ability to create scenarios where they're isolated.

But I'm repeating myself. Plz not to be harming the felines, though.