[craigthedeac]

There isn't much disagreement going on, it's just different perceptions, IMO.

It seems TWP/crowd are assuming "rational" ranges that can be defined, while Strasser/Durr/company are taking the "flip a coin" approach and saying that since the ranges are often unclear, the bet will sometimes work both ways.

The bet accomplishes the same thing regardless of your perception, it's just some people are conceiving of a linear range that has a break-even point, while some people are acknowledging the randomness of what is going on in a hand so the range is "grouped" as Strasser says.