[RunDownHouse]

[ QUOTE ]
That had to be a botched double steal. Only possible explanation.

[/ QUOTE ]
Yeah, that's what the SC anchor duder said hesitantly. From the clip, though, the catcher pretty clearly tries to signal a pitch out while the pitcher is in the middle of his motion. The pitch is high an outside, so it works, but sometime during the delivery/catch, the Cards' batter also seems to motion Pujols back to third. The problem is that Pujols is maybe 10-15 feet from the plate. Even so, Pujols stops, then starts again, at which time its an easy tag.

If you're a runner, it seems like once you're that close there is zero chance of stopping and then reaching any base safely, short of an error. I have to wonder if it was just instinct or surprise that made Pujols stop, or if he honestly misjudged a ball so badly he thought he could make it ~80 feet back to third.