Re: ***Official Top 9 Show Thread***
[ QUOTE ]
For Jordin - technically her breathing was way off at the beginning of her performance last night (she was gasping and not singing from her diaphragm, it was blatant)... but she doesn't get a demerit for me here. In fact, it makes her seem more human and imbues her with some personalitiy. It rounds her out - she's the young, inexperienced, bubbly but very talented girl.
[/ QUOTE ]
I dunno, isn't this giving someone points for NOT singing well? Would people like Melinda more if she sang like she was breathing through an oxygen mask?
|