View Single Post
  #9  
Old 02-13-2007, 07:23 PM
atomicsoda atomicsoda is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: brooklyn
Posts: 190
Default Re: How My Son\'s Insight May Have Saved Poker

[ QUOTE ]
David,

Can't this be applied to BlackJack as well? Clearly, you cannot win at blackjack (sans card counting), but one player can lose money faster than another (hitting on 19 and such). I know here in CA, Blackjack is a game of skill, but we all know it's not a game you can beat longterm.

EDIT: I suppose this assumes that winning long-term is requisite for being a game of skill. To discount my own argument, you could introduce a game of poker with a 20% uncapped rake. No player in the world could beat it long term, but some players could lose faster than others.

[/ QUOTE ]

Whether you can win or not doesn't make it a game of skill or not. BJ could easily be +EV without counting if BJ pays 2/1 instead of 3/2. That doesn't change the skill equation. If you want a game with no skill try Baccarat. Pure luck.
Reply With Quote