[Crveballin]

Standard 5X5 Roto Scoring. You can keep 3 to 5 keepers.
Positions: C,1B,2B,SS,3B,MI,CI,OF(4X) SP(3X),RP(3X),P(4X), 5 bench

I am only allowed to keep a player for 3 years then either have to be traded or waived. The number of years I have kept them is located next to their name.

My potential keepers:
Vladimir Guerrero (2)
David Ortiz (0)
Ryan Howard (0)
Roy Halladay (1)
Matt Holliday (0)
Michael Young (1)
Eric Bedard (0)


I am 100% keeping Vlad, Ortiz, and Howard. 90% sure I will keep Halladay. Who should I keep with the 5th keeper?

Mainly its between Young or Holliday. All opinions are welcome.