Re: The \"disease\" of alcoholism.
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
How to test if something is a disease.
1. Offer sufferer $1,000,000,000 to stop smoking, drinking, having cancer, eating to much, having diabetes etc for one week
2. If they accept it's not a disease!
[/ QUOTE ]
If they accept or if they carry out the deal? Obviously everyone would accept. The question is, would they be able to deliver?
This is a good point. What do you think the alcoholic would do if offered this deal? He would probably spend every dime he had on every possible treatment plan, take it incredibly seriously, pay someone huge amounts to follow him around all day and prevent him from drinking, etc. He could probably win this bet. But aren't the previously listed things, then, just the 'cure?'
[/ QUOTE ]
Also, 'alcoholism' is not equivalent to 'drinking'. I think pretty much everyone would agree that cessation of drinking for one week doesn't make you any less of an alcoholic.
|