Re: Peyton Manning, Greatest QB of all time?
[ QUOTE ]
Let me ask you this... what would Peyton have to do over the rest of his career to make you say he was better than Brady? What would it take?
[/ QUOTE ]
This is a tough question. Let me say that I think that our dispute here is not over how we rate Manning; I think our dispute is that I rate Brady higher than most of you all. I think we're all pretty much in somewhat agreement on Manning.
Its hard for me to answer because I view Brady so highly. It would be like if someone asked me "What does Kobe Bryant have to do to make you think that hes better than Jordan?" I mean sure Bryant could end up better with a great second half of his career, but its just hard to say that someone is outright better than Jordan.
Obviously winning another SB would go a long way. I'd also like to see what he does with below average surrounding talent. For example, my opinion of Montana went up a ton after I saw him in Kansas City.
Its hard to give an outright answer to that question really. Sorry.
|