Re: Capital Punishment For Murderers
[ QUOTE ]
A giant sea tortoise has more cells and a longer lifespan than a human. Is it thus a more valuable creature than humans?
Come on now, surely someone can give it a better try than this.
[/ QUOTE ]
I was only attacking your first statement, that a human has no more worth than ANY other creature.
Dolphins have a bigger brian than a human, for instance, but we were not comparing a human to a dolphin, but a human to all other creatures.
Regardless, here's another argument:
There is no such thing as "worth" in any universal sense - it is an entirely human concept, rooted in the human ego. As such, it is defined as a human may define it. Thus a human can simply define humankind as "more worthy" as it is a value based judgment that arises from human ego in the first place.
AB
|