[ QUOTE ]
Steve Sax would hardly be considered a Scrub.
[/ QUOTE ]
This was my exact thought when I read the OP. Then 5 people followed suit and picked him. If you're one of the 3 top players on your team and made multiple all-star teams (5), you shouldn't be considered a scrub.
Steve Sax's Career Stats and Accolades
My pick:
Joe Girardi
My favorite fictional scrub is obviously Tony Miceli (2nd baseman for the Cardinals)