[jedi]

[ QUOTE ]

Just to reiterate something I said in a previous hero thread: All of Issac's paintings have come true. While Peter saved Claire, all the visuals remained unchanged. In addition, remember Peter had to finish the paiting with the cheerleader lying dead at Sylar's feet. Peter lacked Issac's technical skill so there was no way to tell the identity of the cheerleader in that painting.

It's entirely possible they saved the wrong cheerleader.

[/ QUOTE ]

While the painting came true (cheerleader dead), you're right that they couldn't tell the identity of the cheerleader. Nevertheless, I think they saved the right cheerleader. Claire was the one with the powers, not uber-bitch Jessie. Remember, just because they saw something in the painting doesn't mean they interpreted it correctly.