[ QUOTE ]
Dom: You interpreted the question correctly. Yes, I meant that the film had to be on the list to be elevated to Top 10 status.
For more surprising picks, take a look at the Directors list, which differs slightly from the critics. Also give some clues as to what's missing from the critics.
Director's List
And if someone wants to answer yet another question:
What film on either list most provokes the response "WTF?"
[/ QUOTE ]
For me, it's
Touch of Evil. A very good film but one that doesn't deserve to be in the 50 of all-time.