[MrMon]

I'd say Unitarian or Reform Judaism, depending on how much Jesus you through in the mix. If you think of Jesus as the Messiah, that rules out Judaism, unless you take the Messianic Judaism route, but let's not go there. However, if you just accept Jesus as a spiritual teacher, there are some liberal Jewish congregations where you'd fit in without too much trouble. Unitarianism is more likely your choice, however. Or Ethical Society.