What is it that you are trying to accomplish/improve?
craig, what are you looking for as the final result of your efforts as you've detailed them?
Are you looking to cut down on the number of threads?
Are you looking to weed out potential "salespeople" and fake chest-thumpers?
Are you looking to make it easier to ignore a poster's threads, if they are not up to snuff?
Are you looking to simplify your job as moderator?
As to the W-L records- since those numbers mean very little without validation, wouldn't it be better to list 2+2 posted win/loss records? Those can be verified and judged accurate; other sources usually cannot, due to control questions.
I personally think I'd rather see one "Picks of x/x/06- (sport)" thread that everyone replies to, rather than having to drill down into craig's baseball picks for the week, then find mr baseball and drill down into his for Friday's picks, then hit tech's weekly thread.... and so on.
I am curious what your objectives are here. Given some of the constraints of the forum software, and Search facilities, I don't know if what you're imposing is going to be helpful or not.
Can you give some examples of what you expect the forum to be like?
|