Nice report.
I havent tried the Macallan yet, so I`m looking forward to it. I prefer the Laphroaig myself. I really like peaty scotches.
I still keep a bottle of Dalwhinnie at home. Some of my frieds really enjoy it because it is a lot "easier" than eg. Laphroaig or Lagavulin.
This site is really great btw. Lots of tasting notes:
Maltmadness