[Sluss]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
My averages are set to only record when someone started the QB. However, Here are the week by week breakdowns for the two.



Favre:
12
16
36
8
19
23
22
13
25
21
7
14
22
30

Avg. 19.14

Collins:
14
7
12
6
25
14
11
30
30
6
36
17

avg. 17.33


[/ QUOTE ] I think you flip flopped them

[/ QUOTE ]


The last two numbers are playoff weeks.

Plus, no one picked Collins up until his fourth week. So the numbers are set for only when that QB was started. I had to manually put in Collins's first four games in the interest of fairness. I did not put in Collins's playoff numbers. Since the guy who picked up Collins made the playoffs and the guy who had Favre did not.

Even with the full breakdown they are pretty even. That is with Collins starting the year without a training camp and learning the offense after being thrown into the fire. Favre has been running the same offense since 1993.

The real point here is Favre is no longer the elite quarterback he was. Yes, he is still a very viable option and is in that seven or eight QB group behind Manning, McNabb and Culpepper. I feel like he is in the middle to back of that pack. However, if there is an early run on QBs and he is the highest ranked one left in the 6th, 7th or 8th rounds when I start to think about picking up a QB then I won't be unhappy if I get him. That's a far cry fron three years ago when I was jumping on him in the 3rd round.