[pipster]

Didn't Chris Simms win his playoff game w/ Tampa Bay against a more experienced quarterback? That was the only young QB which looked good... Well Carson Palmer for his 1 play but that doesn't count. Eli Manning looked horrid.

[ QUOTE ]
This is probably the worst game to have to pick. It all depends on which Carolina team shows up. The team that dominated the last two weeks over relatively good opponents. Or the team that has lost to Miami and New Orleans and barely scraped out wins against Green Bay and Detroit.

There's also the experienced QB vs. First-time playoff QB which last week was a sweep for the experienced QBs. This is a tough one...

[/ QUOTE ]