engagement over who gets the ring?
 

a guy and a girl are engaged for 8 months as part of a 4 1/2 year relationship.

the guy cheats on the girl and it appears that the relationship will no longer continue due the the wishes of the girl, the guy wants to work things out.

from a non legal standpoint, is the girl entitled to keep the ring if the guy wants it back or should she return it to the guy?

Re: engagement over who gets the ring?
 

She gets to keep it and it's not close.

Re: engagement over who gets the ring?
 

[ QUOTE ]
a guy and a girl are engaged for 8 months as part of a 4 1/2 year relationship.

the guy cheats on the girl and it appears that the relationship will no longer continue due to the guy cheating, the guy wants to work things out.

from a non legal standpoint, is the girl entitled to keep the ring if the guy wants it back or should she return it to the guy?

[/ QUOTE ]

Re: engagement over who gets the ring?
 

From a legal standpoint he gets the ring.

Re: engagement over who gets the ring?
 

Shyt, like this pisses me off. Are you so stupid you had to make two posts? You couldnt go back an edit? GD IT!!!!

Re: engagement over who gets the ring?
 

girl keep the ring almost always, regardless of circumstances.

unless she throws it back at the dude in a fit of rage

Re: engagement over who gets the ring?
 

[ QUOTE ]
From a legal standpoint he gets the ring.

[/ QUOTE ]

what legal standpoint is that?

Re: engagement over who gets the ring?
 

[ QUOTE ]
Shyt, like this pisses me off. Are you so stupid you had to make two posts? You couldnt go back an edit? GD IT!!!!

[/ QUOTE ]

Settle down buddy it isn't a big deal.

Re: engagement over who gets the ring?
 

That it is a conditional gift.

Re: engagement over who gets the ring?
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Shyt, like this pisses me off. Are you so stupid you had to make two posts? You couldnt go back an edit? GD IT!!!!

[/ QUOTE ]

Settle down buddy it isn't a big deal.

[/ QUOTE ]

I see it all the GD time and me and ElD are sick of it!