Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

I think TDS is more consistently funny -- e.g. pretty much money in the bank on any given night -- but when TCR is *on*, it's heads and shoulders better.

Flame away.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

I think TCR sorta gets old. I agree that looking at one show it might be funnier. But how he talks and acts sorta gets old.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

I think Colbert Report is funnier. But the show does seem very formulaic. I miss the Even Stevphen segments on The Daily Show. [img]/images/graemlins/frown.gif[/img]

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
I think TDS is more consistently funny -- e.g. pretty much money in the bank on any given night -- but when TCR is *on*, it's heads and shoulders better.

Flame away.

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree with this whole heartedly. Colbert is either funny as hell or just flat. Gold or iron. I like the Colbet Report better than the Daily Show but I also think that the Daily show is in decline.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

The Colbert Repoir sucks. Colbert is only funny when he has 5 minute segments on The Daily Show like he use to. Give him a half hour, and his suckiness is revealed.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

Colbert Report is funnier. Better segments ("on notice," "threatdown," "i called it," "the word," etc.) and farr farrrr better interviews. I usually watch the first 2/3 of the daily show, then switch to sportscenter for 10 minutes while Jon interviews whoever, then back for all of Colbert.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
I think TDS is more consistently funny -- e.g. pretty much money in the bank on any given night -- but when TCR is *on*, it's heads and shoulders better.


[/ QUOTE ]

I agree and I'm a huge Daily show fan. When I saw the first episode of TCR, I was sure there was no way it had any legs. Seemed like SNL skit trying to be a movie-just not enough material. I was wrong. Colbert's act never seems to get old. I only wish he could get better guests. Some are outstanding, but some shouldn't even get interviewed on public access television.

This will seem like an odd choice, but the guest I've liked the most was Dermot Mulroney. He seemed to really get it.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

Colbert:Dalily Show::PTI:Sportscenter

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

He was [censored] great on TDS. I only watched the first few Colbert Reports and didn't think it was that great for a full half hour, haven't really watched it since. It was definitely a bummer because I was expecting good things.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
but I also think that the Daily show is in decline.

[/ QUOTE ]

the daily show has been in decline since jon stewart took over as host

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

The Colbert report is funnier.

Then again, I don't find JS funny all the time. In particular, I don't like his little high-pitched whining that he likes to do during his monologue. I also think he tends to botch his interviews. Sometimes just by making jokes that bomb, and sometimes by kissing ass too much. I do like his interviews that get hard-hitting though.

I think Colbert is a better comedic tallent. I also tend to prefer his interviews, which are faster-paced and often put the guest in silly situations. Some of the skits that he does, such as debating himself, are no good though.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

I was actually just thinking of this and discussed it with a friend. I do feel the Colbert Report has surpassed The Daily Show. He's just a funny guy. His style could get old quick though, I don't watch it every day.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
but I also think that the Daily show is in decline.

[/ QUOTE ]

the daily show has been in decline since jon stewart took over as host

[/ QUOTE ]

This is the truest thing you have ever posted since you've won your nobel sex prize.

Btw, I haven't seen you around in a while, it's good to see you post again.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
but I also think that the Daily show is in decline.

[/ QUOTE ]

the daily show has been in decline since jon stewart took over as host

[/ QUOTE ]

Craig Kilborne??? Horrible. The "5 questions" bit he did every interview was lame.

edit: wow, im getting the f out of here. severely outnumbered

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
but I also think that the Daily show is in decline.

[/ QUOTE ]

the daily show has been in decline since jon stewart took over as host

[/ QUOTE ]

Craig Kilborne??? Horrible. The "5 questions" bit he did every interview was lame.

edit: wow, im getting the f out of here. severely outnumbered

[/ QUOTE ]

Seriously. That show was unwatchable until John
Stewart took over.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
I think TDS is more consistently funny -- e.g. pretty much money in the bank on any given night -- but when TCR is *on*, it's heads and shoulders better.


[/ QUOTE ]

I tend to agree, however, I think Colbert's interviews are generally significantly better than Stewart's. That being said, I wish they didn't feel compelled to have a guest every show. I realise it eats a lot of time that's probably a lot easier to write, still, I'd rather they were both more picky about their guests and only had people on when it's really warranted. Maybe 2-3 guests a week, each.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
Some of the skits that he does, such as debating himself, are no good though.

[/ QUOTE ]

????
Formidable Opponent is a truly genius bit.
If it's done in real-time (which it appears to be), it takes a hell of a lot of talent on SC's part.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

I think the news coverage on the daily show is stronger, but the colbert interviews are way better than the daily show. I'm extremely impressed with the colbert report in general.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
Colbert:Dalily Show::PTI:Sportscenter

[/ QUOTE ]
It's closer to Colbert : Daily Show :: PTI : Around the Horn

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

As Kataffy said, Colbert is at his best when he is interviewing. Whether it's the guest or the representative from 'better know a district' his interviews are gold.

OTOH, TDS's interviews suck, but I still think their 'bits' are way better

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
but I also think that the Daily show is in decline.

[/ QUOTE ]

the daily show has been in decline since jon stewart took over as host

[/ QUOTE ]

word

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

The DS show gets first dibs on guests and most material. If it were to get cancelled and the CR got the best material from the DS, everything would be peachy.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
I think the news coverage on the daily show is stronger, but the colbert interviews are way better than the daily show. I'm extremely impressed with the colbert report in general.

[/ QUOTE ]

I still dont understand how the Colbert Report gets the guests that they do. Dont the guests from those different districts already know that the show does not take them seriously and has only invited them to me mocked?

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

Jon Stewart grinding his ax against bush gets old. The Daily Show used to be alot funnier when they made fun of non-political stuff as well.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I think the news coverage on the daily show is stronger, but the colbert interviews are way better than the daily show. I'm extremely impressed with the colbert report in general.

[/ QUOTE ]

I still dont understand how the Colbert Report gets the guests that they do. Dont the guests from those different districts already know that the show does not take them seriously and has only invited them to me mocked?

[/ QUOTE ]

I think they think it makes them look hip.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

Re: the interviews -- Jon Stewart has a reputation to protect and thus has to kiss some serious guest ass.

But because Colbert is essentially doing a 'schtick' the entire time (that of an over-the-top Sean Hannity-uberRepublican), he has more license to challenge his guests and essentially act like a d:ck, because it all feeds into his 'bit.'
That's why he can be more candid (in my opinion...which counts more now, since i just entered 'poo-bah' territory)

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Colbert:Dalily Show::PTI:Sportscenter

[/ QUOTE ]
It's closer to Colbert : Daily Show :: PTI : Around the Horn

[/ QUOTE ]
ship it

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

IMO, TDS is overtaken by any show on TV, even Simple Life, and the Soup.

I would respect the Daily Show much more if they changed the title to "George Bush + America sucks", because at least they would be straightforward.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
IMO, TDS is overtaken by any show on TV, even Simple Life, and the Soup.

I would respect the Daily Show much more if they changed the title to "George Bush + America sucks", because at least they would be straightforward.

[/ QUOTE ]
The part that cracks me up about this is that Colbert is really making more fun of Bush and the Republicans than the DS.

The Daily Show still does the best job of calling out politicians both Democrats and Republicans. You say something that condradicts what you said before and DS has the clip. Plus I love This Week in God.

Colbert started off weak and has become much better. The Word has become something you have to watch every night. Sometimes the schtick goes over the top on me. I hate his interviews. They were funny when they were a guy who liked to collect body lint, when it is a nobel prize winner things get a little out of hand. But it does crack me up when he cheers for himself when he goes over to do the interview, then I turn it off.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

both are brilliant. both are totally different.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
IMO, TDS is overtaken by any show on TV, even Simple Life, and the Soup.

I would respect the Daily Show much more if they changed the title to "George Bush + America sucks", because at least they would be straightforward.

[/ QUOTE ]

you realize that their only job is to make a mockery of politics and politics are absouletely dominated by republicans right now. not to mention that our country makes terrible decisions daily. im pretty sure there is more to it than them hating republicans. saying that the simple life beats it really invalidates your viewpoint further.

rj

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

TCR is funny, but TDS is just fantastic. The way Stewart does the news is really just unparalleled.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
Jon Stewart grinding his ax against bush gets old. The Daily Show used to be alot funnier when they made fun of non-political stuff as well.

[/ QUOTE ]

Bingo!


JunkHead

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
but I also think that the Daily show is in decline.

[/ QUOTE ]

the daily show has been in decline since jon stewart took over as host

[/ QUOTE ]
How much influence does Stewart have over the content? Does he write all the material that he does on the show or do they have a team of writers that has stayed the same through multiple hosts?

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
TCR is funny, but TDS is just fantastic. The way Stewart does the news is really just unparalleled.

[/ QUOTE ]
Bush is probably the easiest Presidential target since Richard Nixon. Do you seriously expect him to avoid this? The "Bush is Stupid" jokes almost write themselves at this point.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
IMO, TDS is overtaken by any show on TV, even Simple Life, and the Soup.

I would respect the Daily Show much more if they changed the title to "George Bush + America sucks", because at least they would be straightforward.

[/ QUOTE ]

you realize that their only job is to make a mockery of politics and politics are absouletely dominated by republicans right now. not to mention that our country makes terrible decisions daily. im pretty sure there is more to it than them hating republicans. saying that the simple life beats it really invalidates your viewpoint further.


[/ QUOTE ]

Of course he doesn't. People like him only notice when their guy gets blasted. JS regularly blasts liberals and rightfully so. When the power shifts, so will the focus.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

Colbert is now the better show.

It wasnt for the first 2 weeks of its run though.

Also, there are a very large number of running gags that many wouldnt get if they didnt watch quite regularily.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
Bush is probably the easiest Presidential target since Richard Nixon. Do you seriously expect him to avoid this? The "Bush is Stupid" jokes almost write themselves at this point.

[/ QUOTE ]

Plus, no one seemed to mind the two years of Clinton BJ jokes that basically lasted through the first year of Bush.

And no Clinton was a dream for comic relief as was Reagan. Bush is just easy to criticize. Not as easy to come up with funny jokes.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
IMO, TDS is overtaken by any show on TV, even Simple Life, and the Soup.

I would respect the Daily Show much more if they changed the title to "George Bush + America sucks", because at least they would be straightforward.

[/ QUOTE ]

you realize that their only job is to make a mockery of politics and politics are absouletely dominated by republicans right now. not to mention that our country makes terrible decisions daily. im pretty sure there is more to it than them hating republicans. saying that the simple life beats it really invalidates your viewpoint further.

rj

[/ QUOTE ]

You're wrong. I used to love the show. Then it changed. Go back and watch some shows from ca. 2000 and compare them to now. If you don't realize it is a Bush-bashing machine, then you need to step back and re-evaluate. The show was much better years ago when it didn't take itself so seriously.

Re: Has the Colbert Report overtaken The Daily Show?? Discuss.
 

I [img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img] both shows, that is all.

I do agree that the Daily Show suffered from the loss of Colbert though.