Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Here's the rules.

You provide general scoring, # of teams, and players. No keeper leagues. I give a one letter evaluation (A+, B-, F, etc.). I will likely give no elaboration on the grade, though I may. Take it or leave it, post it in this thread if you give a bleep.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

You got a 12-team league I can join?

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

12 team league, 1Q, 2RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 DEF.
4 pt. pass TD....6 pt. others. 15 rush/rec yds = 1 pt. 40 passing = 1 pt. typical D and K.

Peyton
LT
Shaun Alexander
Holt
R. Moss
T. Gonzo.
Vanderjagt
Balt Defense.

Okay, thats my team, now rate it.

(kidding of course. I'll probably grade real teams posted here too.)

Josh

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

A+

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Not another one. I did join a 12-team $1k league, but it just filled up yesterday.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

10 teams i have 4th pick standard yahoo scoring
1 qb 3wr 2rb te 1w/te 1k 1def

alexander
a green
holt
d jackson
chambers
vick
baltimore
burress
santana moss
elam
barlow
mcnair
tampa bay
harrington
ma clayton
heath miller
nugent

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

14 team league, 1QB 3WR 2RB 1TE 1wr/rb 1DEF 1K
standard yahoo rules, all TDs are 6, 50yds per QB pt, 20 yds per WR or RB pt
6th position in draft order

Priest Holmes
Julius Jones
Javon Walker
Tatum Bell
Kerry Collins
Roy Williams
Ashley Lelie
Larry Johnson
Mike Williams
Lee Suggs
Joey Harrington
Jeb Putzier
Najeh Davenport
Michael Jenkins
Jeff Reed
San Diego

This draft took place ago almost exactly 2 weeks ago

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

14 Teams. 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1 DEF, 1 PK. 4 Bench Players.

1 pt for 50 yds passing, 20 rushing or receiving. 6 pts for 1 TD passing, rushing or receiving. Rest is pretty standard I think.

QB J Plummer DEN

RB J Lewis BAL
RB S Jackson STL
RB D Foster CAR
RB C Buckhalter PHI
RB C Perry CIN

WR M Clayton TBY
WR J Smith JAX
WR D Givens NED
WR T Williamson MIN

TE R McMichael MIA

DT Carolina Panthers

PK J Reed PIT

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Start 1 Qb 2 Rb 3WR 1 Rb/wr 1 K and 1 Defense
Standard Scoring TD pass-4, all other TD's-6 1 pt. 20 yards passing, 1 pt. 10 yards rushing/receiving, no points for receptions


12 team league (12th pick)
QB- Michael Vick
QB- David Carr
RB- Deuce McAllister
RB- Rudi Johnson
RB- J.J. Arrington
RB- Frank Gore
RB- Dominic Rhodes
RB- Kenny Watson
WR- Nate Burleson
WR- Roy Williams
WR- Rod Smith
WR- Brandon Stokley
WR- Antonio Bryant
K- David Akers
DE- Baltimore Ravens

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

u picked in that order?

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

That's just my sqaud, not drafted in that order obviously.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

i was about to say lol

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

B

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

A-

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Roster Positions:
1 QB
2 WR
2 RB
1 TE
1 Flex (WR or RB)
1 K
1 Team Defense
6 Bench

Stat Categories:
Passing Yards (20 yards per point)
Passing Touchdowns (4)
Interceptions (-2)
Rushing Yards (10 yards per point)
Rushing Touchdowns (6)
Reception Yards (10 yards per point)
Reception Touchdowns (6)
Return Touchdowns (6)
2-Point Conversions (2)
Fumbles Lost (-2)
Offensive Fumble Return TD (6)
Field Goals 0-19 Yards (3)
Field Goals 20-29 Yards (3)
Field Goals 30-39 Yards (3)
Field Goals 40-49 Yards (4)
Field Goals 50+ Yards (5)
Point After Attempt Made (1)
Sack (1)
Interception (2)
Fumble Recovery (2)
Touchdown (6)
Safety (2)
Block Kick (2)
Points Allowed 0 points (10)
Points Allowed 1-6 points (7)
Points Allowed 7-13 points (4)
Points Allowed 14-20 points (1)
Points Allowed 21-27 points (0)
Points Allowed 28-34 points (-1)
Points Allowed 35+ points (-4)

16 teams, all from the sporting events forum.

1 La Dainian Tomlinson RB
2 Chris Brown RB
3 Trent Green QB
4 Jerry Porter WR
5 Larry Fitzgerald WR
6 Correll Buckhalter RB
7 Marshall Faulk RB
8 Byron Leftwich QB
9 Bubbha Franks TE
10 Jets Defense
11 Mike Nugent K

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

C+

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

# of teams? That's critical info. Your grade for a 10 team league is nothing like your grade for a 14 team league.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

i only see 11 players and your league calls for 15. What am I missing?

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

i only see 11 players and your league calls for 15. What am I missing?

Dohhhh [img]/images/graemlins/blush.gif[/img]... I should wait for the draf to finish before I put up my team....to be continued [img]/images/graemlins/crazy.gif[/img]

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

So the obvious follow-up is why are you drafting a crappy kicker 5 rounds before the end of the draft?

And a more general question to (seemingly) everyone else. What's with spending quality 4th-6th round picks on Vick and the Ravens?

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

10 Team Leauge normal yahoo scoring.

QB- P. Manning
QB- J. Plummer
WR- R. Wayne
WR- A. Boldin
WR- E. Kennison
WR- L. Fitzgerald
WR. M. Williams
TE- D. Clark
TE- R. McMichael
RB- C. Martin
RB- C. Brown
RB- C. Williams
RB- R. Brown
K- M. Vanderjagt
DEF- Baltimore


Also would you recommend getting another RB? Thanks.

Edit- Just picked up Ronnie Brown and dropped K.C. DEF

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Draft #1:
1 pt. per 10 yds. rushing/receiving
1 pt. per 25 yds. passing
6 pts. per TD...rushing/receiving/passing

1. Kevin Jones
2. Domanick Davis
3. McNabb
4. Larry Fitzgerald
5. Plax Burress
6. Warrick Dunn
7. Antonio Gates (keeper pick)
8. Derrick Mason
9. TJ Duckett
10. David Carr
11. Pats D
12. M. Faulk
13. Troy Williamson
14. Ryan Longwell
15. Doug Jolley
16. Matt Jones

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

10 team league, I have 9th pick.

6pt pass/rush/receive TD,
1pt 20 yards rush/reveive,
1pt 50 yards pass
K/D usual
-2 int/fumble

Draft order
10 - P. Holmes RB
13 - D. McAllister RB
30 - J. Walker WR
33 - A. Johnson WR
50 - D. Brees QB
53 - M. Vanderjact K
70 - A. Brooks QB
73 - Atlanta D
90 - D. Foster RB
93 - A. Lelie WR
110 - E. Johnson TE - (traded for TJ Duckett (FA))
113 - M. Bennett RB
130 - M. Anderson RB (traded for L. Evans (FA))
133 - L. Coles WR

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Your firstb 4 picks are super-solid. HOlmes is an absolute steal at 9--get Larry Johnson.

Your next 4 picks are super-awful.

Also, you got Laverneus in the LAST [censored] ROUND? Seems clear you're playing with morons. That said, you should have done better for yourself.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Jesus christ, i hope this leagues is for some serious cash- that team looks sick. Who the hell were the other 11 teams drafting in the first 4 rounds to le you get LT,SA,PM and RM?

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

[ QUOTE ]
Jesus christ, i hope this leagues is for some serious cash- that team looks sick. Who the hell were the other 11 teams drafting in the first 4 rounds to le you get LT,SA,PM and RM?

[/ QUOTE ]

I believe he was kidding.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Custom league, QB dominated league.

1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1 K, 1 D

8 team league

Passing TD- 5 pts
Rushing TD- 6.5 pts
Receving TD- 5.5 pts

1 pt every 25 passing yards
1 pt every 10 rushing yards
1 pt every 15 receiving yards

.5 pts every 1 completion
1 pt every 1 reception

Qbs average 25-32
Good rbs average 22-25
Wrs average 17-19
Defenses average around 12-13
Kickers average 6-9

I had 2nd overall and traded it 2nd overall and 14th rounder for 5th overall and 6th rounder.

1 (5)- Donovan Mcnabb
2 (15)- Deuce Mcallister
3 (18)- Javon Walker
4 (31)- Curtis Martin
5 (34)- Antonio Gates
6 (44)- Steve Smith
6 (47)- Derrick Mason
7 (50)- Phily Defense
8 (63)- JJ Arrington
9 (66)- Larry Fitzgerald
10(79)- Jake Delhomme
11(82)- Adam Vinatieri
12(95)-DeShaun Foster
13(98)-Santana Moss
No 14th rounder

I'd like a grade for the draft, althought it's worth noting that my roster now looks nothing like that. I'm addicted to action to I offer 25-30 trades per day [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

If anyone cares, my starting lineup is now this:

QB- Peyton Manning
RB- Deuce McAllister
RB- Brian Westbrook
WR- Mushin Mohammed
WR- Steve Smith
WR- Derrick Mason
TE- Antonio Gates
K- David Akers
Def- Baltimore

I like the second one better [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

12 team league.

scoring: tds=6
passing= 1/25yds
rushing and recieveing = 1/10yds

computer drafted for me but i made some changes. this is what im left with.

starters:
carson palmer
tatum bell
cory dillon
isaac bruce
darrell jackson
randy mcmichael
shayne grraham
redskins d

reserves:
steve mcnair
ricky williams
larry fitzgerald
michael jenkins
marcus pollard

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Standard Yahoo league (6 for TD), 10 teams.

STARTERS
QB: M. Hasselbeck
RB: Alexander, K. Jones
WR: Holt, Walker, Mason
PK/TE/DEF: None, but plenty on free agent list.

BENCH
RB: Westbrook, T. Bell, M. Anderson, Bettis, Duckett, F. Gore
WR: Lelie, Fitzgerald, Evans

PLEASE QUOTE ON REPLY GRADE.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

[ QUOTE ]
C+

[/ QUOTE ]

In what universe is that team slightly above average?

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

[ QUOTE ]
Standard Yahoo league (6 for TD), 10 teams.

STARTERS
QB: M. Hasselbeck
RB: Alexander, K. Jones
WR: Holt, Walker, Mason
PK/TE/DEF: None, but plenty on free agent list.

BENCH
RB: Westbrook, T. Bell, M. Anderson, Bettis, Duckett, F. Gore
WR: Lelie, Fitzgerald, Evans

PLEASE QUOTE ON REPLY GRADE.

[/ QUOTE ]

I'm not Clark but this is a [censored] good team. A+ from where I'm sitting.

You mght rely a lil too much on the Seattle O. That might be nmy only concern here.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Standard Yahoo scoring, 10 teams, 8th pick.

1. (8) E. James
2. (13) K. Jones
3. (28) J. Horn
4. (33) R. Wayne
5. (48) Ro. Williams
6. (53) K. Barlow
7. (68) A. Lelie
8. (73) M. Bennett
9. (88) R. McMichael
10. (93) A. Brooks
11. (108) D. Givens
12. (113) B. Roethlisberger
13. (128) M. Nugent
14. (133) Cincinnati
15. (148) J. Gaffney

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

solid d.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

[ QUOTE ]
14 Teams. 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1 DEF, 1 PK. 4 Bench Players.

1 pt for 50 yds passing, 20 rushing or receiving. 6 pts for 1 TD passing, rushing or receiving. Rest is pretty standard I think.

QB J Plummer DEN

RB J Lewis BAL
RB S Jackson STL
RB D Foster CAR
RB C Buckhalter PHI
RB C Perry CIN

WR M Clayton TBY
WR J Smith JAX
WR D Givens NED
WR T Williamson MIN

TE R McMichael MIA

DT Carolina Panthers

PK J Reed PIT


[/ QUOTE ]

Did you fall asleep during the third round?

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Roster Positions: QB, WR, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, K, DEF, BN, BN, BN, BN, BN, BN
Stat Categories: Passing Yards (50 yards per point)
Passing Touchdowns (6)
Interceptions (-2)
Rushing Yards (20 yards per point)
Rushing Touchdowns (6)
Reception Yards (20 yards per point)
Reception Touchdowns (6)
Return Touchdowns (6)
2-Point Conversions (2)
Fumbles Lost (-2)
Offensive Fumble Return TD (6)
Field Goals 0-19 Yards (3)
Field Goals 20-29 Yards (3)
Field Goals 30-39 Yards (3)
Field Goals 40-49 Yards (4)
Field Goals 50+ Yards (5)
Point After Attempt Made (1)
Sack (1)
Interception (2)
Fumble Recovery (2)
Touchdown (6)
Safety (2)
Block Kick (2)
Points Allowed 0 points (10)
Points Allowed 1-6 points (7)
Points Allowed 7-13 points (4)
Points Allowed 14-20 points (1)
Points Allowed 21-27 points (0)
Points Allowed 28-34 points (-1)
Points Allowed 35+ points (-4)

Team 1:
1. L. Tomlinson
24. C. Johnson
25. T. Owens
48. F. Taylor
49. C. Brown
72. D. Staley
73. M. Muhammad
96. B. Leftwich
97. B. Stokley
120. B. Griese
121. B. Edwards
144. B. Franks
145. Philadelphia
168. F. Gore
169. J. Reed

Team 2:
2. S. Alexander
23. T. Gonzalez
26. S. Jackson
47. T. Brady
50. L. Coles
71. C. Chambers
74. D. Branch
95. T. Henry
98. C. Pennington
119. M. Vanderjagt
122. Buffalo
143. B. Lloyd
146. M. Williams
167. B. Roethlisberger
170. V. Jackson

Team 3:
3. P. Holmes
22. T. Holt
27. L. Jordan
46. C. Williams
51. S. Smith
70. Ro. Williams
75. A. Brooks
94. R. McMichael
99. L. Johnson
118. M. Anderson
123. G. Lewis
142. Carolina
147. N. Davenport
166. K. Warner
171. J. Wilkins

Team 4:
4. P. Manning
21. M. Harrison
28. B. Westbrook
45. D. Foster
52. K. Barlow
69. D. Driver
76. Baltimore
93. P. Burress
100. K. Colbert
117. T. Williamson
124. S. Davis
141. L. Smith
148. H. Miller
165. S. Janikowski
172. M. Moore

Team 5:
5. W. McGahee
20. K. Jones
29. A. Johnson
44. M. Hasselbeck
53. D. Bennett
68. T. Heap
77. Ro. Smith
92. T. Duckett
101. S. McNair
116. A. Toomer
125. J. McCareins
140. P. Price
149. D. Akers
164. D. Blaylock
173. St. Louis

Team 6:
6. D. McAllister
19. R. Johnson
30. J. Walker
43. Mi. Clayton
54. C. Benson
67. K. Collins
78. A. Lelie
91. J. Delhomme
102. R. Droughns
115. C. Cooley
126. D. Givens
139. N. Goings
150. J. Elam
163. Tampa Bay
174. J. Jurevicius

Team 7:
7. R. Moss
18. C. Martin
31. T. Green
42. A. Boldin
55. J. Arrington
66. A. Crumpler
79. C. Palmer
90. M. Robinson
103. K. McCardell
114. C. Rogers
127. Cincinnati
138. T. Jones
151. Washington
162. L. Tynes
175. D. Jolley

Team 8:
8. E. James
17. T. Barber
32. A. Gates
41. B. Favre
56. I. Bruce
65. J. Porter
80. Ji. Smith
89. M. Faulk
104. Ke. Johnson
113. K. Robinson
128. New England
137. J. Harrington
152. R. Longwell
161. D. Graham
176. M. Pittman

Team 9:
9. J. Lewis
16. J. Jones
33. R. Wayne
40. N. Burleson
57. W. Dunn
64. L. Fitzgerald
81. J. Plummer
88. E. Kennison
105. J. Bettis
112. Pittsburgh
129. A. Vinatieri
136. D. Bledsoe
153. J. Wiggins
160. R. Caldwell
177. A. Bryant

Team 10:
10. C. Dillon
15. D. Davis
34. H. Ward
39. M. Bulger
58. M. Bennett
63. D. Brees
82. D. Mason
87. Da. Clark
106. Ma. Clayton
111. A. Randle El
130. E. Johnson
135. J. Hanson
154. J. Pathon
159. Chicago
178. D. Terrell

Team 11:
11. D. Culpepper
14. A. Green
35. T. Bell
38. M. Vick
59. J. Shockey
62. S. Moss
83. E. Moulds
86. M. Stover
107. D. Boston
110. Atlanta
131. J. Galloway
134. E. Manning
155. Indianapolis
158. S. Graham
179. B. Troupe

Team 12:
12. C. Portis
13. D. McNabb
36. D. Jackson
37. J. Horn
60. J. Witten
61. R. Brown
84. L. Suggs
85. L. Evans
108. D. Stallworth
109. T. Houshmandzadeh
132. D. Carr
133. R. Williams
156. New York
157. E. Shelton
180. J. Brown

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

[ QUOTE ]
Team 11:
11. D. Culpepper
14. A. Green
35. T. Bell
38. M. Vick

[/ QUOTE ]

I love it when people do stuff like this in a draft. Have fun with those WR's, team 11!

And do you want Clark to grade all of those teams? I'd say the chance of that happening is about 0.03%.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Standard yahoo rules. 10 teams

Starters
K collins
E mmoulds
J smith
D Givens
S alexander
T barber
A Gates
J wilkins
Def Baltimore


Bench
C brown
J Dellhomme
S moss
R droughns
R williams
J mcareins

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

Standard Yahoo Scoring. 10 Team League. 16 Players Max.

Tom Brady
Byron Leftwich
Clinton Portis
Julius Jones
Lamont Jordan
Cedric Benson
T.J. Duckett
Randy Moss
Michael Clayton
Marcus Robinson
Charles Rogers
Jason Witten
Heath Miller
Mike Vanderjagt
Philadelphia Eagles Defense

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

[ QUOTE ]

Tom Brady
Byron Leftwich
Clinton Portis
Julius Jones
Lamont Jordan
Cedric Benson
T.J. Duckett
Randy Moss
Michael Clayton
Marcus Robinson
Charles Rogers
Jason Witten
Heath Miller
Mike Vanderjagt
Philadelphia Eagles Defense


[/ QUOTE ]

Wow, either one of your backs or Randy Moss fell quite a ways. (My best guess is it was J. Jones, not sure why people are apprehensive about him.) Overall somewhat solid, although I don't think the backup TE, and to an extent, QB, are necessary. Another RB and WR would be nice.

Re: Clark Rates your FF draft
 

[ QUOTE ]
Standard Yahoo Scoring. 10 Team League. 16 Players Max.

Tom Brady
Byron Leftwich

[/ QUOTE ]

If you must draft a backup QB -- and I don't see why you should -- at least draft a guy with a different bye week.