Quote:
Quote:
There's no reason anybody should vote for me this turn because even if I turn out to be a wolf, it means you're a wolf too. Plus, there's only one of us who hasn't yet lied to everyone.
This makes no sense
Assume for a second that perg is telling the truth. He's sacrificed 2 villagers already (AL and bennies) plus another one tonight. So he's sacrificed 3 villagers to "prove" that I'm a wolf. Add to this the fact that I was already suspected of being a wolf and this plan makes no sense whatsoever. He hasn't really proven anything about me, he only claims that this proves I'm a wolf (which is also unfounded).
This plan only makes sense if he's a wolf executing it on his own or if it's a truly elaborate bluff and we're executing it together. In either case, he's a wolf and should be executed.
Perg is obviously an intelligent individual and I don't think that he would make this play by accident.
Go back and reread my posts and his posts and tell me which ones make sense. Also, consider which one of us hasn't told the group an elaborate lie.
Quote:
Also, why have you changed your vote so much?
OK
Day 1:
First I voted for Apathy. I realized he wasn't playing, so I voted for TwistedEcho (essentially random)
Next, I changed my vote to kyro because his behavior seemed suspect to me. I had no reason to believe TE was a wolf and didn't want to vote for psyduck for reasons that have been discusses ad nauseum.
Day 2:
I stuck with kyro (no change from my last vote, and pergesu promptly seconded that vote). I then became convinced that he was truly innocent. He seemed way too defensive to be a wolf, given that the group hadn't really put any pressure on him and I was really the only one who had. I wasn't really convinced Perg was a wolf, but he was *very* quick to jump on. I decided to vote for him as more of an unvote for kyro, just to show him that I had faith in him.
Since I didn't really believe perg was a wolf at that point, I looked for someone else that made sense at that point, and bones seemed to fit the bill well.
After that, perg said he was the seer. It seemed really bad that an innocent would do this, so he was either a wolf or telling the truth. I did the analysis that I presented in my numbers posts and decided it had to be worth the risk to vote for AL.
|