TwistedEcho
He's From England!
Reged: 05/17/05
Posts: 3913
|
|
i vote for GreekHouse
Something doesn't add up.. hes either trying too hard as a villager or its certainly possible hes a wolf. Until someone presents a more compelling argument for someone else, my vote goes this way i think.
|
GreekHouse
Man Eating Lobster
Reged: 08/18/04
Posts: 2042
Loc: Zoidberg...for TWO!!!
|
|
Quote:
Btw i've played this game before (altho slightly different rules) on another site, and day one is pretty much pointless if people know how to play - the wolves shouldn't give anything away and you might as well bandwagon vote someone until you have more information. Its not like we are going to be able to work out a wolf from the first killing unless the seer got lucky, or one of the wolves sucks and makes it stupidly obvious.
It's a mistake to assume that the Wolves will not screw up in round 1. This is the first time most of these people have played this game. Last time, the seer was able to correctly guess two wolves in round 1 and identify them in the subsequent nights. When everyone started piling on psyduck it was completely ridiculously obvious he wasn't actually a wolf.
Now, somebody needs to back my vote for bones or tell me why I'm wrong.
|
ALReturnsLOL
phu_1, the sickest LAG by far
Reged: 07/16/05
Posts: 4474
Loc: Averett 4 lyfe
|
|
Quote:
I was just babbling to Bones over AIM (he was an obvserver), so my chat wasn't "shady" at all. Yer the only shady one, which is why you should be hanged.
erm, isn't it aganist the rules though for villagers to communicate with each other? I mean even if you weren't talking about wolf, its kinda aganist the nature of the game. I stated great reasons why I can't be the wolf, if the bandwagon jumps on me they will be sorry.
|
jgunnip
Carpal \'Tunnel
Reged: 10/06/04
Posts: 5321
Loc: shipping ironman bonus medals
|
|
Quote:
i vote for GreekHouse
Something doesn't add up.. hes either trying too hard as a villager or its certainly possible hes a wolf. Until someone presents a more compelling argument for someone else, my vote goes this way i think.
If greek is a wolf, then he's a very active one and I think its tough for any active wolf to keep his cover for more than a couple of days.
I'm suspicious now too of good2cu but since he's gonna go get all straight balla on some scrippa batches I'd hate to see him get mobbed without the chacne to defend himself.
sjc has only spoken twice. first time he voted for kyro, then he switched his vote to psyduck (third person that voted for him). I vote sjc
|
Costanza
enthusiast
Reged: 08/15/04
Posts: 345
Loc: The armpit of the South
|
|
Quote:
Now, somebody needs to back my vote for bones or tell me why I'm wrong.
Oh, what the hell.
I change my vote to Bones.
|
kyro
Nose Pwner
Reged: 05/23/04
Posts: 24320
Loc: Melting Sabrina
|
|
My list...
GreekHouse pergesu
I don't think these people are wolves...
AlReturns good2cu
I am on the fence with bones and TwistedEcho right now. Also, I think 1 or 2 of bennies/Costanza/castanza_g are wolves.
|
bones
STTF-USP Champion
Reged: 06/17/04
Posts: 5768
Loc: Blogging on icons
|
|
Quote:
Quote:
I was just babbling to Bones over AIM (he was an obvserver), so my chat wasn't "shady" at all. Yer the only shady one, which is why you should be hanged.
erm, isn't it aganist the rules though for villagers to communicate with each other? I mean even if you weren't talking about wolf, its kinda aganist the nature of the game. I stated great reasons why I can't be the wolf, if the bandwagon jumps on me they will be sorry.
I didn't mean to imply that perg did anything illegal. He just wasn't online for awhile and it was taking forever to get started. He got back and we got moving.
|
GreekHouse
Man Eating Lobster
Reged: 08/18/04
Posts: 2042
Loc: Zoidberg...for TWO!!!
|
|
Quote:
i vote for GreekHouse
Something doesn't add up.. hes either trying too hard as a villager or its certainly possible hes a wolf. Until someone presents a more compelling argument for someone else, my vote goes this way i think.
I challenge you to look at my posts and find one flaw in my logic. The reason I've been active is because I saw a reason for my activity. The reason obviously is that I saw the village ready to lynch an innocent person and stepped in. Next, I stepped in this turn, defended what I said the previous turn and tried to lead the village toward a reasonable conclusion.
I challenge you to find one good reason that a wolf would play the game the way I have.
|
kyro
Nose Pwner
Reged: 05/23/04
Posts: 24320
Loc: Melting Sabrina
|
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
I was just babbling to Bones over AIM (he was an obvserver), so my chat wasn't "shady" at all. Yer the only shady one, which is why you should be hanged.
erm, isn't it aganist the rules though for villagers to communicate with each other? I mean even if you weren't talking about wolf, its kinda aganist the nature of the game. I stated great reasons why I can't be the wolf, if the bandwagon jumps on me they will be sorry.
I didn't mean to imply that perg did anything illegal. He just wasn't online for awhile and it was taking forever to get started. He got back and we got moving.
Hmmmmmm.....
Pergesu?
|
pergesu
Carpal \'Tunnel
Reged: 02/03/04
Posts: 5201
Loc: i ain't got my taco
|
|
Quote:
Quote:
I was just babbling to Bones over AIM (he was an obvserver), so my chat wasn't "shady" at all. Yer the only shady one, which is why you should be hanged.
erm, isn't it aganist the rules though for villagers to communicate with each other? I mean even if you weren't talking about wolf, its kinda aganist the nature of the game. I stated great reasons why I can't be the wolf, if the bandwagon jumps on me they will be sorry.
As I said in my post...
BONES WAS AN OBSERVER
He didn't play. I didn't have communication with another villager. I was just like, "Wow I don't have a clue what's going on, but I'm pretty sure Lori's a wolf, and I'm going to stick to it so when I'm right everyone will want my nuts." That's about the same thing as I said to kyro.
|